Submission review/2

WikiCulture & Community (2001-2999)

No.	Title	Presenter (first author)	Vote 1 (Iván Martínez)	Vote 2 (Deror Lin)	Vote 3 (James Forrester)	Vote 4 (Gregory Varnum)	Vote 5 (Kiril Simeonovski)	Vote 7 (Edward Saperia)	Vote 10 (Pepe Flores)	Vote 11 (Andrés Cruz y Corro)	Vote 12 (Anna Torres)	Vote 13 (Luis Álvarez Azcárraga)	Final Score	Comments
2001	Why Wikimedia Fails: The Origins of Power, Prosperity, and Poverty (talk)	User:MADe	10	10	9	9	10	10	10	9	9	7	9.300
2002	The coolest projects of Wikimedia Chapters - be inspired (talk)	User:deror avi	10	COI	10	10	10	10	10	10	9	7	9.556
2003	#100wikidays (talk)	User:Spiritia	10	9	8	9	10	7	9	8	10	8	8.800
2004	Activating communities across Africa with Kumusha Takes Wiki and Wiki Loves Africa (talk)	User:Anthere	8	10	9	9	9	7	10	10	10	9	9.100
2005	An Orphan Wants to be Adopted (talk)	User:Ovedc	9	9	8	9	7	9	10	9	8	8	8.600	Deror: Was this lecture given in a previous year? not sure.
2006	AfroCROWD: From Black Twitter to Black Wikipedia? (talk)	User:aliceba	7	8	7	8	7	8	9	7	8	9	7.800
2007	Beyond anarchy. Options for a Wikimedia government (talk)	User:Pgallert	9	8	8	7	8	8	7	7	8	8	7.800	Luisalvaz: When we use some theoric and political concepts so complexes as anarchy, we need a theorical framework, I think.
2008	Birth of a project to preserve a 2500 years old language (talk)	User:psubhashish	10	8	8	9	7	7	9	8	9	9	8.400
2009	Crowd control - How to build effective community monitoring for crowdsourced projects (talk)	User:Rebecca Cotton	9	8	9	8	9	8	7	8	10	9	8.500	Deror: Or we can accept as a workshop
2011	Religion and Wikipedia – opening the gate for closed cultural groups. (talk)	User:Arielinson	10	10	8	8	9	7	9	9	9	9	8.800
2012	Engineering Volunteering - How to best design volunteer support in the Wikimedia movement (talk)	User:Rebecca Cotton	9	9	9	9	10	9		9	9	8	9.000
2013	Environment and Encyclopedia: How to write about green issues from a global perspective? (talk)	User:Toter Alter Mann	8	9	8	8	8	6		9	9	8	8.111
2014	Evaluativism: Strategic concern in authoritative collaborations (talk)	User:langchri	9	4	5	5	3	8		7	5	9	6.111
2016	How to interest people in contributing to Wikimedia? (talk)	User:Ochilov	5	4	6	5	4	2		7	7	6	5.111
2017	How to transfer «power» from one to another Chapter Board «without pain» (talk)	User:perohanych	5	3	2	1	1	7		4	4	6	3.667
2018	1 Year to get your things done and to present them at Wikimania Esino Lario (talk)	User:Atropine	10	10	10	10	10	9		10	10	8	9.667
2019	Edit-a-thons for bridging the gender gap on Wikimedia (talk)	User:Netha Hussain	9	10	10	10	9	4		9	10	8	8.778
2020	Wikipedia community directory (talk)	User:cherishsantosh	5	7	7	7	4	3		4	5	8	5.556
2021	WOW and Wikipedia: With Women-Only Workshops Against the Gender Gap (talk)	User:Trans Goat	10	10	8	10	10	4		8	9	9	8.667
2022	Wither the Gender Gap (talk)	User:Rich Farmbrough	10	10	7	8	9	9		8	9	8	8.667
2023	How to Build a Regional Cooperation: A Story from CEE Region (talk)	User:Ліонкінг	9	9	9	9	COI	7		9	10	9	8.875
2024	Measuring the immeasurable: toward a qualitative evaluation of gender gap activities (talk)	User:Atropine	10	10	8	9	9	10		10	10	8	9.333	Note: This is a discussion not a panel.
2025	2005-2015 - From the Wikimedia Annual Conference to Wikimania: 10 years, what has changed, what hasn't? (talk)	User:notafish	10	10	10	10	10	10		9	9	7	9.444
2026	7 Amazing Facts about Wikipedia Readers. Number 3 Will Make You Cry (talk)	User:YWelinder (WMF)	10	10	9	10	10	10		8	9	8	9.333
2027	Keeping Wiki #1 : encouraging accurate, diverse and tolerant Wiki editing (talk)	User:startarrant	5	3	5	5	2	4		3	5	6	4.222	Andrés I do not understand the specific purpose of this submission
2028	KISS new editors (talk)	User:Rebecca Cotton	10	10	9	9	8	10		8	6	8	8.667
2029	Kannada language, Linguistic Heritage & FOSS with Wiki Projects (talk)	User:Omshivaprakash	8	6	7	8	6	4		7	9	8	7.000
2030	Jensen on "Quality comparison of history articles in English, German, French and Spanish Wikipedias" (talk)	User:Rjensen	10	9	8	8	8	4		9	8	9	8.111
2031	Q & A the other way: Meet the Erasmus laureates (talk)	User:Man77	8	8	8	8	8	9		7	8	9	8.111	Note: This is a discussion not to be videoed
2032	Quality matters - How to support learning and improvement in Wikimedia organizations (talk)	User:Claudia.Garad	10	10	8	9	10	10		8	9	8	9.111
2033	Different cultures of Wikipedias: how major projects differ in perceiving quality (talk)	User:Pundit	10	10	10	9	10	10		9>	9	8	9.444
2034	Do you feel heard? A Community Liaisons Roundtable (talk)	User:Rdicerb (WMF)	10	10	10	10	10	9		10	9	7	9.444
2035	Revolutionizing article creation using Content Translation (talk)	User:Santhosh.thottingal	9	10	9	10	9	7		9	9	9	9.000
2036	Regional meetings: working towards common goals (talk)	User:Anna Torres (WMAR)	10	10	9	9	10	7		10	COI	9	9.250
2037	Failures that made us better: A brief history of the Wikimedia Foundation as a learning organization (talk)	User:Tbayer (WMF)	10	10	10	10	10	9		9	9	8	9.444
2038	From Foundation to Federation: The Last Piece of the Puzzle (talk)	User:Eloquence	10	10	COI	9	10	10		9	10	9	9.625
2039	Funding the movement's dreams: How FDC works and help build strong organizations (talk)	User:Matanya	10	10	9	9	9	9		8	10	7	9.000
2040	Get inspired for activity revolution (talk)	User:Kiril Simeonovski	10	10	8	9	COI	7		9	8	9	8.750
2041	Going Global: Creating and Growing a Wikipedia Library Branch in Your Own Language (talk)	User:PEarley (WMF)	9	10	9	10	9	8		10	9	9	9.222
2042	Undeclared Paid Advocacy Editing, Enforcing the Terms of Use, Whose Job is it? (talk)	User:Doc James	10	10	8	8	8	9		8	9	8	8.667
2043	Understanding gender and skills gaps beyond Wikipedia (talk)	User:KrystleChung	10	10	9	9	9	10		8	10	9	9.333
2044	Volunteer engagement in the Wikimedia movement (talk)	User:Wolliff (WMF)	10	10	9	10	9	7		9	10	8	9.111
2045	Podemos! How Videos are bringing Wikimedia to the next Level (talk)	User:Fuzheado	10	10	10	10	10	7		9	9	9	9.333
2046	Video Community Coordination Roundtable (talk)	User:Fuzheado	10	10	10	10	10	7		9	9	8	9.222	Deror: Note this is a Workshop
2047	Vandalism, Spam, Death Threats, and More: A Day in the Life of a Wikipedia Admin (talk)	User:HJ Mitchell	10	9	8	8	7	8		9	8	9	8.444
2049	“Idea support” - Going new ways in volunteer support to help turn ideas into successful projects (talk)	User:Veronika Krämer (WMDE)	9	10	8	9	10	9		9	8	8	8.889
2050	Headhunting of volunteers (talk)	User:Kiril Simeonovski	10	10	8	8	COI	10		8	10	8	9.000
2051	Authority Control: How it applies to you (talk)	User:Pigsonthewing	8	10	8	9	9	9		9	8	9	8.778
2052	A flight through the Wikiverse: Defining identities in the Wikimedia movement (talk)	User:Gnom	9	10	9	10	10	2		8	9	8	8.333	Note: This is a discussion
2053	A global discussion forum: does Meta-Wiki really work? (talk)	User:Pmlineditor	9	10	8	8	7	9		8	8	10	8.556
2054	A wikiHow Update (talk)	User:JackHerrick	8	6	10	8	5	7		7	7	5	7.000
2055	Are we really an educational tool? Reviewing and improving articles related to the international curricula to serve educational needs and to rebalance information geography on Wikipedia. Pilot in South Africa. (talk)	User:iopensa	10	10	8	8	8	10		8	9	9	8.889
2056	Art+Feminism Campaign: Lessons Learned (talk)	User:OR drohowa	10	10	8	9	8	7		7	9	8	8.444
2057	Ask the Designers (talk)	User:Pginer-WMF	10	10	9	10	9	8		8	9	8	9.000
2058	Ask Us Anything About Wikidata (talk)	User:Lydia Pintscher (WMDE)	10	10	10	9	10	9		10	9	7	9.333
2059	Balancing Quality and Engagement on a Growing Wiki (talk)	User:KrystleChung	8	8	8	9	7	10		7	7	9	8.111
2060	Best practices for meetup pages (talk)	User:Another Believer	6	3	8	9	4	7		4	7	8	6.222
2061	Beyond VisualEditor (talk)	User:Jdforrester (WMF)	10	10	COI	10	10	10		8	10	8	9.500
2062	Building up Wikidata, country by country (talk)	User:Jheald	10	10	8	9	9	8		9	9	9	9.000
2063	Burning down the house: Engineering teams communicating externally (talk)	User:KLans (WMF)	7	6	8	9	6	7		7	7	7	7.111
2064	Can Conflicts of Interest (COI) be aligned with the Wikimedia project? (talk)	User:WWB	9	10	8	10	9	9		8	9	10	9.111
2065	Civility 101 (talk)	User:Fabrice Florin (WMF)	10	10	7	10	6	6		9	9	8	8.333	Note: This is a discussion.
2066	Collaborative drafts (talk)	User:Adamw	9	10	8	9	4	10		8	8	10	8.444	Note: This is a discussion
2067	Coloniality of power in Wikimedia, a vision from Global South (talk)	User:salvador alc	10	9	7	8	8	6		8	9	9	8.222
2068	Content Translation - translathon and discussion (talk)	User:Amire80	10	10	9	10	9	7		7	10	8	8.889	Note: This is a workshop.
2069	Covering the Wikimedia Community (talk)	User:Fuzheado	10	10	10	10	10	10		8	10	9	9.667
2070	Crossing borders - international collaboration on GLAM projects (talk)	User:Pigsonthewing	10	10	8	8	10	7		10	9	8	8.889
2071	#Edit2015, a community curated Year-In-Review video (talk)	User:VGrigas (WMF)	10	10	9	10	7	5		7	9	8	8.333
2072	Engaging with Community Engagement (talk)	User:LuisV (WMF)	10	10	10	10>	10	10		9	10	6	9.444
2073	Everything the Wikimedia Foundation does, in 25 minutes (talk)	User:Tbayer (WMF)	10	10	10	10	10	10		9	10	8	9.667
2074	Help assist Wikipedia writers in developing countries to educate the world (talk)	User:Fred Timbee	5	2	4	5	8	3		3	10	9	5.444
2075	How a small chapter grows - Strategy to facilitate local community with limited resources (talk)	User:Shangkuanlc	5	2	6		2			4	7	6	4.571	"Unsure if submitter would give in Chinese or English. More positive if the latter, given the audience." (Comment by User:Jdforrester "I don't understand the language, but based on the title, I think It would be an interesting presentation. Putting a lower score based on the lack of knowledge of a language it's a little bit unfair, I think".--Luisalvaz (talk) // I believe both comments are correct. I am concerned for the actual spread of this presentation's knowledge.
2076	How can the Wikimedia Blog help you? (talk)	User:Fabrice Florin (WMF)	9	10	7	8	9	9		9	9	8	8.667	Note: This is a discussion.
2077	How can we communicate better as a movement? (talk)	User:Fabrice Florin (WMF)	10	10	7	10	9	7		8	8	9	8.667	Note: This is a discussion.
2078	How do editors interact on article level and do they show territorial behaviour? (talk)	User:Stefankasberger	9	7	7	8	10	10		8	7	10	8.444
2079	How to improve the coverage of women in Wikipedia (talk)	User:Victuallers	9	10	8	9	9	7		9	10	10	9.000
2080	How to write an elaborate article about an individual asteroid (talk)	User:Gereon K.	6	6	5	6	7	6		6	4	8	6.000
2081	How Wikidata helped me to correct errors in articles whose languages I don't speak (talk)	User:Harmonia Amanda	9	8	9	8	8	7		10	8	8	8.333
2082	IdeaLab Workshop: Making Ideas into Action (talk)	User:Siko (WMF)	10	10	8	10	10	9		8	9	8	9.111	Note: This is a workshop.
2083	Illustrating History: Image restoration for Wikipedia (talk)	User:Adam Cuerden	8	10	7	8	9	8		7	8	8	8.111
2084	Inspiring Friendly Spaces: What we learned from running a gender gap campaign on-wiki (talk)	User:Siko (WMF)	10	10	9	10	9	8		10	9	8	9.222
2085	Is Two the Magic Number?: The Co-op and New Editor Engagement through Mentorship (talk)	User:I JethroBT	10	10	9	9	10	8		10	10	8	9.333
2086	Is Wikimania no longer for Authors? (talk)	User:Marcus Cyron	9	10	6	7	7	6		8	9	8	7.778
2087	La construcción de Wikipedia en español desde el ámbito local. Estrategias y tácticas de los wikipedistas mexicanos (talk)	User:Luisalvaz	7	4	3	5	3			7	6	COI	5.000
2088	Learning & Evaluation Poster Session (talk)	User:JAnstee (WMF)	8	2	8	8	8	9		8	8	8	7.444	Kiril: This is a unique type of submission demanding space and logistics. // Andrés: I like the idea, but am worried about this exact point.
2089	Lessons from psychology about wiki communities (talk)	User:MartinPoulter	8	10	8	8	10	10		8	8	8	8.667
2090	Let's talk about bees: What a single Wikipedia article can tell us about Wikipedians (talk)	User:Guillaume (WMF)	9	10	9	9	8	10		9	8	9	9.000
2091	Leveraging volunteers through programs (Programs evaluation 2015 review and recommendations) (talk)	User:JAnstee (WMF)	9	10	9	10	10	9		8	10	8	9.222
2092	Mainstream media as a reliable source in Wikipedia (talk)	User:Mapep	9	7	7	7	8	9		9	8	9	8.111
2093	Mapping the Maps -- Help geolocate 50,000 maps and load them fully categorised onto Commons (talk)	User:Jheald	8	10	8	8	10	8		8	8	10	8.667
2094	MediaWiki Stakeholders' Meetup (talk)	User:Mglaser	8	8	8	10	8			8	8	8	8.250	Probably should be in the tech track. / Ed: Isn't this a meetup? is that a separate thing?
2095	Microgrants as a way to motivate editors (talk)	User:Лорд Бъмбъри	7	8	7	8	9	7		7	7	9	7.667
2096	My life as an autistic Wikipedian (talk)	User:guillom	10	10	9	10	9	7		8	10	9	9.111
2097	Myths about Wikipedia (talk)	User:Ziko	7	9	8	8	8	8		7	8	9	8.000
2098	Not your Internet (talk)	User:Jaredzimmerman (WMF)	9	10	9	9	9	9		7	10	7	8.778
2099	Observed Edit Patterns in the wild. (talk)	User:Jeph paul	8	7	7	7	7	7		8	7	8	7.333
2100	Offline work without a chapter: what can you do? (talk)	User:Strainu	7	9	8	9	8	7		7	8	8	7.889
2101	OpenStreetMap workshop (talk)	User:aude	9	10	8	10	10	7		9	9	10	9.111	Note: Workshop, also a tradition on wikimanias.
2102	OTRS - An Introduction (talk)	User:Matthewrbowker	10	10	8	9	8	7		9	9	7	8.556
2103	Our options for addressing harassment of women, LGBT+ people, and other popular targets for discrimination (talk)	User:bluerasberry	9	10	9	COI	9	9		9	10	10	9.375
2104	Personal invitations, coffee and small talk - how weekly editathons may solve the gender bias on Swedish Wikipedia (talk)	User:Hannibal	10	10	10	10	10	7		10	10	9	9.556
2105	Pluricentric languages and Wikipedia - where to draw the line... and where not to (talk)	User:Braveheart	10	10	9	8	10	7		8	9	10	9.000
2106	Real-Time Collaborative Editing (talk)	User:cscott	10	10	9	10	8	10		10	9	10	9.556
2107	Running a successful (international) Wikimedia event (talk)	User:Danny B.	10	10	7	8	9	8		9	10	8	8.778
2108	Setup a permanent local community space (talk)	User:Sylvain WMFr	10	10	9	9	9	8		10	10	9	9.333
2109	Shared cognition, knowledge and content production: the embodied noosphere logs in (talk)	User:AGreen (WMF)	9	7	8	8	8	7		8	9	10	8.222
2110	Sharing nice: Teaching large enterprises how to change knowledge management with open collaboration (talk)	User:Ckoerner	8	7	9	9	9	7			9	9	8.375
2111	Show Me the Money - Here's your Global Financial Report (talk)	User:MGuss (WMF)	10	10	9	10	10	10			10	9	9.750	Deror: I think 30 min is enough
2112	Small projects: Caught in a trap (talk)	User:Juandev	8	8	8	7	8	6			7	9	7.625
2113	Someone is wrong on the Internet: seven simple ways to fix our fails (talk)	User:Coren	8	9	9	8	8	8			8	8	8.250
2114	State of the Cuteness: a state of mind for shaping the future of the Wikimedia movement (talk)	User:Percy Plush	10	10	8	9	8				8	9	8.857	As the submitter is nominally a soft toy, perhaps we should demand some details on the panel's speakers? :-) Possibly this should be scheduled as an after-dinner presentation/panel of fun rather than in the main tracks?
2115	State of Wikidata - giving more people more access to more knowledge one edit at a time (talk)	User:Lydia Pintscher (WMDE)	10	10	9	10	10	10			8	9	9.500
2116	State of Wikimedia Scholarship 2014-2015 (talk)	User:Benjamin Mako Hill	10	10	10	10	10	10			10	9	9.875
2117	Are you staying or are you going? (talk)	User:henna	10	10	10	9	10	10			10	9	9.750
2118	Supersize Me! - Growth Hacking for Developing Wiki Groups (talk)	User:Pineapples100	9	10	9	9	10	10			10	8	9.375
2119	Systemic bias beyond demography (talk)	User:Pgallert	9	9	9	8	8	9			9	10	8.875
2120	The (Broken?) Promise of Wikimagic: The Life, Death and Rebirth of Boldness and Constructive Collaboration on Wikipedia (talk)	User:Sky Harbor	9	7	8	8	9	7				10	8.286
2121	The Art of Trolling (talk)	User:southpark	10	10	9	8	8	8			8	9	8.750
2122	The Effect of Blocking IP Editing: Evidence from Wikia (talk)	User:Benjamin Mako Hill	10	10	10	10	9	10			8	10	9.625
2123	The future of Wikimedia movement (talk)	User:Millosh	10	10	7	7	10	6			9	9	8.500
2124	The medical translation project as seen from the translators side (talk)	User:Enrique Cavalitto	9	10	8	8	8	6			8	9	8.250
2125	The Peelian Principles - A Victorian Solution to Community Issues (talk)	User:Panyd	8	6	9	8	6	8			7	9	7.625
2126	The Perfect Policy Proposal (talk)	User:Beeblebrox	7	6	8	8	4	7			7	5	6.500
2127	The pictures are on Commons. Now what ? (talk)	User:Léna	8	10	8	9	10	6			8	7	8.250
2128	The Power of Photography in a Wikiworld (talk)	User:Skyrunner75	8	10	7	8	8	5			9	8	7.875
2129	Welcome home: How local community spaces spur collaboration (talk)	User:Gnom	10	10	8	9	10	7			8	8	8.750	Possibly merge with 2108?
2130	Welcome to the Internet, Assholes (talk)	User:Jaredzimmerman (WMF)	10	10	9	9	9	10			8	7	9.000
2131	What can Google do for you? (talk)	User:Denny	9	9	8	7	8	10			7	7	8.125
2132	Where Are the Women in Wikipedia? (talk)	User:Margott	10	10	8	9	10	6			9	8	8.750
2133	Why English Isn't Enough (talk)	User:Siebrand	10	10	8	10	8	5			9	8	8.500
2134	Why user groups are awesome, and why you should start one! (talk)	User:80686	8	10	9	COI	9	6			10	7	8.429
2135	Wiki Online - Wiki Offline (talk)	User:Lionel Scheepmans	7	9	8	8	7	7			8	9	7.785	Deror: 30 min are enough
2136	WikiCheese: Steps to launch a successful crowdfunding campaign (talk)	User:Pyb	10	10	9	9	10	6			9	8	8.875
2137	Wikidata Babel workshop (talk)	User:Kvardek du	9	10	7	9	9	7			7	8	8.250	Note: This is a workshop
2138	WikiJournal-The free journal which anyone can access (talk)	User:Thinkmaths	10	4	6	5	4	6			7	9	6.375	Note: Discussion
2139	Wikimedia explorer experience : Feedback, utility, opportunity and new ideas (talk)	User:Lionel Scheepmans	8	8	8	8	8	8			9	9	8.250	Note: Discussion
2140	Wikimedia LGBT+ (talk)	User:CT Cooper	10	10	8	COI	8	6			9	9	8.571
2141	Wikimedia Metrics in the making: What Can We Bring To The Table? (talk)	User:notafish	10	10	8	10	10	9			9	8	9.250
2142	WikiMotivation - why do we use and contribute to Wikimedia? (talk)	User:Stefaniak	8	9	9	9	9	10			9	9	9.000
2143	Wikipedia and Cultural Norms: Cases involving image uploads (talk)	User:Daffy123	8	9	7	7	8	6			7	9	7.625
2144	Wikipedia Gender Inequality Index: Analysing Who We Write About (talk)	User:Maximilianklein	9	10	9	10	10	7			10	8	9.125
2145	Wikipedia in Social media (Socioboard) (talk)	User:VladislavNedelev	8	8	7	9	9	9			7	8	8.125
2146	Wikipedia Vs Terrorism (talk)	User:Ravan	9	9	9	9	9	6			10	10	8.875
2147	Wikipedia Zero Impact in Bangladesh (talk)	User:Aashaa	7	5	8	8	8	8			9	5	7.250
2148	Wikipedia's health: A socio-technical overview (talk)	User:EpochFail	10	10	9	9	10	10			8	10	9.500
2149	Wikiproject X (talk)	User:Isarra	9	10	10	10	9	10			9	7	9.250